FMC to Probe Effectiveness of Punitive Detention and Demurrage Fees
The FMC is researching whether high detention and demurrage fees actually speed cargo movement or simply penalize shippers for unpreventable delays.
The US Federal Maritime Commission (FMC) is seeking research to determine whether detention and demurrage charges that exceed compensatory costs successfully incentivize the movement of cargo. This investigation targets the core justification for escalating fees, questioning whether punitive billing serves a functional purpose in the supply chain or merely adds cost to unpreventable delays.
For shippers and terminal operators, the distinction hinges on the incentive principle. The FMC is focusing on the gap between delays an importer can prevent—such as choosing to leave a container at a terminal despite available trucking appointments—and those they cannot, such as when a box is inaccessible or appointments are unavailable.
The Limits of Incentive-Based Pricing
The regulatory scrutiny suggests a potential shift in how detention and demurrage fees are structured. If the research confirms that higher bills cannot move a box that is physically or operationally stuck, the legal basis for incentive-based pricing may be undermined. This could force carriers and terminals to limit charges to purely compensatory levels when operational bottlenecks are the primary cause of delay.
Current industry friction often arises when shippers are billed for containers that remain under terminal control or lack available pickup slots. By formalizing research into these scenarios, the FMC is moving toward a standard where fees must be tied to the shipper’s actual ability to mitigate the delay rather than serving as a fixed penalty regardless of terminal conditions.
The outcome of this research will likely influence future enforcement of the Ocean Shipping Reform Act, specifically regarding the reasonableness of carrier billing practices during periods of high port congestion.
Source: The Loadstar